Still Great After All These Years: Pizza at Jersey City NJ’s Three Guys from Italy

It’s time to admit that the Snob was once a preppie, having attended St. Peter’s Preparatory High School in Jersey City, NJ.  I somehow managed to overcome those trying years and become the interesting albeit eccentric person that I am today.  Four years of my life, nevertheless, were connected to the northern New Jersey metropolis known as Jersey City.

Back in the day, Journal Square was the center of Jersey City.  In addition to shopping, dining, and transportation, it had two elaborate, historic movie theaters–the Stanley and the Lowes – both now dark but still standing.  The Square today still serves as a major bus terminal and a key stop for the Path train that runs between lower Manhattan and Newark.

Right outside the old Path station once stood a little hole in the wall place that served an awesome slice of pizza: Three Guys from Italy was the prime pizza place for us preppies.  It was a busy place that turned over cheese slices so fast they would inevitably burn the roof of your mouth.

Music City Mike, the Snob’s alter ego, recently went to see his hero Bruce Springsteen perform a few shows in their mutual home state.  The Snob’s mission on this trip was to travel through the Square to see if Three Guys still made a killer slice. Relocating down the street after the old Path station was torn down and rebuilt, Three Guys still makes one of the best slices in the Garden State, or anywhere else for that matter.

Three Guys is your standard pizza joint – order at the counter, take it with you or sit in the back and eat it there. They also offer a few select Italian dishes.  Barely lunch time, I ordered two good-sized $1.75 cheese slices. By sight alone I knew these would be Five Slice Award worthy, and the first bite confirmed it. Three Guys was as good as it was 40 years ago!  Perfectly economical in sauce and cheese with a nice thin crust, the slices had more oil than the usual but were quite flavorful. Cooked to perfection.  Upon leaving, I told the guy at the counter “You just can’t make a slice any better than that!” Textbook NY-Style pie.

The Square may not be what it once was back in the early Seventies, but it can proudly boast being the home of Three Guys from Italy and its masterful pizza. It’s just a short walk from the Path station, and I highly recommend it if you are ever passing through.

PIZZA SNOB RATING   ***** Sets the Standard

Three Guys from Italy
Journal Square
2854 John F. Kennedy Blvd.
Jersey City, NJ
(201) 792-9565
[No website]   



  1. MAURA D. MCGREEVY · · Reply

    Back in the day it was the BEST pizza I ever had….thick crust dripping w/melting cheese topping it w/garlic n salt w/a coke…the price was 2 slices n coke @ a dollar…. so affordable n delicious!!! And it was not inclosed within other buildings….it was smack in the middle of the Concourse!! Believe that was the name of that area.

  2. MAURA D. MCGREEVY · · Reply

    I would die 4 a few slices now…I went there everyday 4 lunch!

  3. My husband worked there during the late 60’s and 70’s…..Best pizza in the Journal Sq. area !

  4. Bob Brohm · · Reply

    Ate there all the time on my way home from Dickinson High…took the kids there on a visit back to JC to show them what real pizza is like..they fell in love with it ..nothing like it in NC

  5. back in the day…they were the only place you could buy a slice…….rain/snow/whatever….2 slices fpr sure

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: