Where I’ve Been: The Snob Reviews

        Latest
Slices  City Pizza Joint (click for review) Date Update
5 Asbury Park, NJ Maruca’s Tomato Pies 4/26/20  
5 Astoria, NY Rosario’s 1/5/19  
5 Atlanta, GA Antico Pizza Napoletana 11/23/18  
5 Atlanta, GA Fellini’s Pizza 8/1/12 9/20/13
5 Atlantic City, NJ Tony Boloney’s 7/13/14  
5 Austin, TX Home Slice Pizza 10/20/13  
5 Bayonne, NJ Brothers Pizza & Pasta 5/3/14  
5 Bayonne, NJ Joe’s Pizzeria  8/14/13 6/28/20
5 Bayonne, NJ Pompei Pizza 9/22/12  
5 Bayonne, NJ Prince of Pizza 9/18/16  
5 Bayonne, NJ San Vito Restaurant 9/22/12  
5 Beverly Hills, CA Mulbery Street Pizzeria 3/1/2016  
5 Bronx, NY Louie & Ernies Pizza 8/7/2016  
5 Brooklyn , NY Di Fara Pizza 2/28/13  
5 Brooklyn , NY Grimaldi’s Pizza 1/17/14  
5 Brooklyn , NY Ignazio’s Pizza 9/9/12  
5 Brooklyn, NY Famous Joe’s of the Village 6/16/18  
5 Brooklyn , NY Juliana’s Pizza 12/23/15  
5 Brooklyn , NY L&B Spumoni Gardens 4/1/14  
5 Brooklyn , NY Lenny’s Pizza 4/14/14  
5 Brooklyn, NY Luigi’s Pizza 6/23/18  
5 Brooklyn, NY Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop 11/10/20  
5 Brooklyn , NY Roberta’s 8/23/17  
5 Brooklyn, NY Table 87 12/18/14  
5 Brooklyn , NY Totonno’s (Coney Island) 2/15/15  
5 Chicago, IL Pequod’s Pizza 3/28/21  
5 Culver City, CA Roberta’s 2/3/19  
5 Denver, CO Fat Sully’s New York Pizza 4/23/17  
5 Denver, CO Two-Fisted Mario’s Pizza 4/23/17  
5 Elizabeth, NJ Santillos Brick Oven Pizza 11/27/13  
5 Elizabeth, NJ Spirito’s Restaurant & Tavern 3/25/17  
5 Florence, ITALY il Pizzaiulo 10/7/15  
5 Fort Worth, TX Zoli’s Pizza 4/27/21  
5 Hoboken, NJ Benny Tudino’s 9/11/12  
5 Hoboken, NJ Basile’s Pizza 12/8/14  
5 Jersey City, NJ Bread and Salt 3/22/20  
5 Jersey City, NJ Prince of Pizza 5/2/16  
5 Jersey City, NJ Razza Pizza Artigianale 7/19/20  
5 Jersey City, NJ Renato’s Pizza Masters 8/25/16  
5 Jersey City, NJ Stadium Pizza 5/29/14  
5 Jersey City, NJ Three Guys from Italy 10/11/12  
5 London, UK Pizza East 6/25/17  
5 Metuchen, NJ Antonio’s Brick Oven Pizza 3/15/20  
5 Montclair, NJ Villa Victoria Pizzeria 3/26/14  
5 Naples, ITALY L’ Antica Pizzeria da Michele 9/30/15  
5 Nashville, TN Bella Napoli Pizzeria 3/4/17  
5 Nashville, TN Five Points Pizza 8/25/12 1/6/19
5 Nashville, TN GaGa’s Grandma Pies 5/9/20  
5 Nashville, TN Joey’s House of Pizza 9/5/12 9/20/13
5 Nashville, TN Manny’s House of Pizza 8/18/12  
5 Nashville, TN Nicky’s Coal Fired 2/11/17  
5 Nashville, TN Smith & Lentz Brewing and Pizza 1/2/23  
5 Nashville, TN Two Boots 10/6/13  
5 New York, NY Bleecker Street Pizza  6/17/13  
5 New York, NY Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern (NYC) 12/25/18  
5 New York, NY Famous Bens Pizza of Soho 12/4/14  
5 New York, NY Gotham Pizza 12/30/17 1/10/21
5 New York, NY Joe’s Pizza 7/19/12  
5 New York, NY Joe’s Pizza (Broadway) 12/23/18  
5 New York, NY Joe & Pat’s NYC 8/10/19  
5 New York, NY Kesté Pizza & Vino 8/21/16 1/10/21
5 New York, NY Patsy’s Pizzeria 7/2/13  
5 New York, NY Phil’s Pizza 10/9/18  
5 New York, NY Proto’s Pizzeria 4/19/20  
5 New York, NY Rivoli Pizza  6/19/14  
5 New York, NY Rivolli Pizza II 11/27/14  
5 New York, NY Rossetti’s Pizza 4/12/16  
5 New York, NY Rubirosa Ristorante 3/25/18  
5 New York, NY Sal & Carmine Pizza  12/27/15  
5 New York, NY Sauce Pizzeria 3/8/19  
5 New York, NY Scarr’s Pizza 7/25/17  
5 New York, NY Spunto Thin Crust Pizza 8/5/19  
5 New York, NY Solo Pizza 12/22/15  
5 New York, NY Two Boots 7/17/16  
5 New York, NY Village Pizza 1/26/15  
5 Phoenix, AZ Pizzeria Bianco 7/19/18  
5 Pittsburgh, PA Mineo’s Pizza House 1/1/17  
5 Port Chester, NY John’s of Arthur Avenue 6/12/18  
5 Rahway, NJ Nancy’s Towne House 3/21/16  
5 Roanoke, VA Benny Marconi’s 1/7/17  
5 Rome. ITALY Pizzeria Ai Marmi 10/11/15  
5 Rome. ITALY Virgilio 9/28/15  
5 Rosemary Beach, FL Lola Coastal Italian 11/13/20  
5 San Francisco, CA Marcello’s Pizza 12/27/16  
5 Sanibel Island, FL Al Forno Al Fresco 8/22/20  
5 Santa Monica, CA Joe’s Pizza 12/31/15  
5 Secaucus, NJ Plaza Pizza 11/12/16  
5 Staten Island, NY Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern 1/11/15  
5 Staten Island, NY Nunzio’s Pizzeria & Restaurant 6/4/14  
5 Sloatsburg, NY Sunnyside’s Bar & Grill 3/15/13  
5 Wayne, PA Paola’s 6/12/2019  
4.5 Avenel, NJ Rocco’s Pizzeria 3/30/19  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ Café Bello 11/16/17  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ Fontana Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant 3/21/16  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ Kuhl’s Tavern 12/29/16  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ La Guardiola Pizzeria & Bistro 5/3/14  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ Pizza Linos 5/3/14  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ Pizza Masters 9/22/12 7/3/16
4.5 Bayonne, NJ Rana’s Pizzeria 12/26/14  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ The Starting Point Bar & Grill 10/28/16  
4.5 Bayonne, NJ The Vic Tavern 4/2/18  
4.5 Birmingham, AL Post Office Pies 1/3/21  
4.5 Brooklyn, NY Best Pizza 11/6/17  
4.5 Brooklyn , NY Vinnie’s Pizzeria 1/27/18  
4.5 Culver City, CA La Rocco’s Pizzeria 1/30/16  
4.5 Denver, CO Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta 4/23/17  
4.5 Denver, CO Benny Blanco’s Pizza 4/23/17  
4.5 Denver, CO Marquis Pizza 4/23/17  
4.5 Destin, FL Mimmo’s Ristorante Italiano 3/5/22  
4.5 Edison, NJ Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza 9/30/18  
4.5 Edison, NJ Attilio Pizza 4/8/18  
4.5 Edison, NJ Brooklyn Boys Pizza 3/19/17  
4.5 Edison, NJ Menlo Pizza & Subs 7/31/17  
4.5 Edison, NJ Zia Lisa Pizzeria and Ristorante 7/14/19  
4.5 Flagstaff, AZ Pizzicletta 7/7/18  
4.5 Florence, ITALY Gusta Pizza 10/4/15  
4.5 Forest Hills, NY Gloria Pizza 2/23/18  
4.5 Franklin, TN Brooklyn Brothers Pizza 3/19/15  
4.5 Hoover, AL Vecchia Pizzeria & Mercato 3/17/22  
4.5 Howard Beach, NY New Park Pizza 12/9/18  
4.5 Jersey City, NJ Carmine’s Pizza Factory 1/29/14  
4.5 Jersey City, NJ The Four Brothers 10/13/16  
4.5 Jersey City, NJ Vinnies III 9/28/16  
4.5 Kingston Springs, TN Skyking Pizza 5/12/21  
4.5 London, UK Homeslice Neal’s Yard 10/14/18  
4.5 London, UK Mulberry Street 5/29/14  
4.5 London, UK Paradise Slice Pizza Shop 11/11/18  
4.5 London, UK Pizza Pilgrims 1/5/20  
4.5 London, UK Sandy’s Too Pizza 1/12/20  
4.5 Metuchen, NJ Woodstack Pizza Kitchen 11/12/20  
4.5 Miami Beach, FL Pucci’s Pizza 5/19/15  
4.5 Miramar Beach, FL Grimaldi’s Coal Brick-Oven Pizzeria 7/6/17  
4.5 Metairie, LA Brooklyn Pizzeria 11/23/12  
4.5 Mt. Juliet, TN NY NY Pizza 10/17/13  
4.5 Nashville, TN Folk 8/22/18  
4.5 Nashville, TN Porta Via Italian Kitchen 11/28/15 3/21/16
4.5 New Brunswick, NJ Filippo’s Famous Pizza 1/27/18  
4.5 New York, NY Angelo’s Pizza 6/5/17  
4.5 New York, NY Artichoke Pizza 2/19/13  
4.5 New York, NY Harry’s Italian 7/8/15  
4.5 New York, NY John’s of Bleecker Street 7/6/13  
4.5 New York, NY Lombardi’s Pizza 2/15/13  
4.5 New York, NY Nonna’s LES Pizzeria 5/8/16  
4.5 New York, NY Pomodoro Ristorante & Pizzeria   12/8/15  
4.5 New York, NY Rose’s Pizza & Pasta 3/22/19  
4.5 New York, NY Sorbillo Pizzeria 4/15/18  
4.5 New York, NY Stromboli Pizza 5/24/15  
4.5 New York, NY Williamsburg Pizza 12/31/17  
4.5 North Arlington, NJ Pizza Land 8/1/13  
4.5 Pittsburgh, PA Benny Fierro’s 9/4/17  
4.5 Port Chester, NY Roddy’s Pizza & Salad 5/30/18  
4.5 Rome, ITALY C’era una volta …la Pizza  9/26/15  
4.5 Roselle Park, NJ Sun Tavern 8/13/2017  
4.5 San Francisco, CA Golden Boy Pizza 3/20/2018  
4.5 San Francisco, CA Jersey Restaurant 3/17/2018  
4.5 San Francisco, CA Pizzeria Avellino 12/27/16  
4.5 Sarasota, FL Piccolo Italian Market & Deli 11/3/19  
4.5 Sarasota, FL Sal’s Pizza & Pasta House 10/12/19  
4.5 Siesta Key, FL Flavio’s Brick Oven Pizza & Bar 9/12/21  
4.5 Siesta Key, FL Il Panificio 8/14/21  
4.5 Siesta Key, FL Ripfire Pizza & BBQ 11/12/19  
4.5 South Orange, NJ Reservoir Restaurant 1/19/18  
4.5 Staten Island, NY Brothers Pizza 11/29/15  
4.5 Staten Island, NY Lee’s Tavern 2/11/13  
4.5 Staten Island, NY Val’s Pizzeria 5/16/16  
4.5 Tampa, FL Bavaro’s Pizza Napolitana & Pastaria 11/28/19  
4.5 Weatherford, TX Nizza Pizza 1/30/13 3/21/14
4 Athens, GA Little Italy Pizzeria 12/27/13  
4 Atlantic City, NJ Jonuzi’s Pizza 7/13/14  
4 Bayonne, NJ Mama Rosa’s Cucina & Pizzeria 3/26/14  
4 Bayonne, NJ Mike’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant 3/1/15  
4 Bayonne, NJ Mona Lisa Pizzeria 4/6/13  
4 Bayonne, NJ 3 Brothers from Italy 7/9/16 12/31/17
4 Berwyn, PA Phil’s Famous Pizza & Steaks 10/4/20  
4 Bradley Beach, NJ Vic’s Italian Restaurant 3/27/16  
4 Brentwood, TN Basil Garden Pizza of Brentwood 11/9/20  
4 Bridgewater Township, NJ Carlo’s Pizza & Pasta 3/8/20  
4 Chattanooga, TN Community Pie 12/27/13  
4 Chattanooga, TN Fiamma Pizza Company 12/28/21  
4 Clifton Heights, PA Gaetano’s Pizzeria 6/2/22  
4 Dallas, TX Serious Pizza 2/3/13  
4 Destin, FL Fat Clemenza’s  2/8/22  
4 Edison, NJ Francesco’s Pizzeria & Restaurant 12/16/18  
4 Edison, NJ Tony’s Italian Restaurant & Pizza 11/20/18  
4 Edison, NJ Villa Gennaro 9/28/20  
4 Elk Grove Village, IL Lou Malnati’s Pizza 10/30/20  
4 Florence, ITALY Panini Pizze e Vini 10/5/15  
4 Ft. Myers, FL Downtown House of Pizza 9/14/20  
4 Fort Worth, TX Campisi’s 8/22/13  
4 Fort Worth, TX Hysen’s Nizza Pizza 3/6/14  
4 Fort Worth, TX Piattello Italian Kitchen 12/12/17  
4 Fort Worth, TX Picchi Pacchi 5/17/15  
4 Franklin, TN Culaccino Italian Restaurant + Bar 6/17/21  
4 Franklin, TN Sal’s Family Pizza 8/12/12 7/13/14
4 Flushing, NY Lucia Pizza 3/19/17  
4 Freehold, NJ Federici’s Family Italian Restaurant 8/1/13  
4 Granbury, TX Nizza Pizza 3/7/15  
4 Inlet Beach, FL Amici 30A Italian Kitchen 1/20/19  
4 Jersey City, NJ Delenio Italian Restaurant 5/1/15  
4 Jersey City, NJ Georgio’s Pizzeria 10/4/16  
4 Jersey City, NJ Vincents Pizzeria & Italian Deli 9/11/16  
4 Lodi, NJ Lodi Pizza 3/29/15  
4 London, UK Camden Pizza Co. 11/4/18  
4 London, UK Ecco Pizza 7/26/15  
4 London, UK Pizza Union 11/2/18  
4 Long Branch, NJ Scala’s Pizzeria 6/12/15  
4 Madison, AL Famous Joe’s Pizzeria 9/9/12  
4 Media, PA Little Anthony’s Pizza 9/17/22  
4 Memphis, TN Memphis Pizza Café 1/1/13  
4 Miramar Beach, FL JBs Pizza to Po’boys 7/9/17  
4 [Mobile] Pie for the People 7/21/12 9/20/13
4 Napa, CA Azzurro Pizzeria 2/5/18  
4 Nashville, TN Bella Nashville Pizzeria 12/27/13  
4 Nashville, TN Crankees Pizzeria 5/23/14  
4 Nashville, TN Lockeland Table 9/10/17  
4 Nashville, TN NY Pie 8/27/12  
4 Nashville, TN Pizza Perfect 8/22/12 7/13/14
4 Nashville, TN ‘za Wood Fired Pizza 4/5/20  
4 Neptune City, NJ Pete and Elda’s Bar / Carmen’s Pizzeria 6/9/15  
4 New York, NY Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza 4/16/14  
4 New York, NY Ben’s Pizzeria 7/13/12  
4 New York, NY Champion Pizza Soho 5/25/15  
4 New York, NY Don Pepi Pizza  11/12/13  
4 New York, NY Famous Original Ray’s Pizza 1/1/7/14  
4 New York, NY La Margarita 12/22/15  
4 New York, NY L’asso Pizza 12/27/15  
4 New York, NY Little Italy 10/11/18  
4 New York, NY Motorino 6/19/14  
4 New York, NY Pizza Suprema  11/27/13  
4 New York, NY Percy’s Pizza 6/28/13  
4 New York, NY Prince St. Pizza 2/8/15  
4 New York, NY Rosa’s Pizza 4/12/15  
4 New York, NY Stanton Street Pizza 12/14/15  
4 New York, NY V&T Pizzeria  6/28/15  
4 New York, NY W4 Pizza 8/17/19  
4 Pittsburgh, PA Fiori’s Pizzaria 11/24/16  
4 Panama City Beach, FL Bubba’s Pizza 12/29/20  
4 Pittsburgh, PA The Original Milano’s Pizzeria 9/3/18  
4 Ramsey, NJ Kinchley’s Tavern 11/15/17  
4 Ringwood. NJ Ringwood Pizza 10/22/12  
4 Rome, ITALY La Rioni 9/27/15  
4 Rome, ITALY Pizza Boom 10/4/15  
4 San Francisco, CA Arinell Pizza 12/18/16  
4 San Francisco, CA Slice House by Tony Gemignani 12/27/16  
4 Sanibel Island, FL Dante’s Coal Fired Pizza 9/6/20  
4 Springfield Township, NJ Saporito Pizza 5/20/15  
4 Staten Island, NY Joe and Pat’s Pizzeria & Restaurant 9/14/12  
4 Staten Island, NY Sharkey’s Square 5/20/16  
4 Vestavia Hills, AL Johnny Brusco’s New York Style Pizza 6/10/13  
4 Vauxhall, NJ Joe’s Famous Pizza 12/2/17  
4 Wanaque, NJ Geppetto’s Pizza 8/17/13  
4 Wayne, PA Vinnie’s Pizza 6/29/19  
4 Weatherford, TX Mamma Monica & Italian Pizza 12/19/21  
3.5 Antioch, TN Angelos’ Picnic Pizza 11/12/12  
3.5 Ardmore, PA Bella Italia Pizza 6/16/19  
3.5 Asbury Park, NJ Porta Pizzeria 7/13/13  
3.5 Atlanta, GA Piu Bello Pizzeria Restaurant 8/1/12  
3.5 Atlanta, GA Vinny’s N.Y. Pizza 10/18/14  
3.5 Athens, GA Transmetropolitan 1/7/14  
3.5 Bayonne, NJ Denapoli Krispy Pizza 5/3/14  
3.5 Bayonne, NJ Prima Pizzeria & Restaurant 9/2/16  
3.5 Berwyn, PA Bravissimo Pizza & Pasta 6/22/19  
3.5 Brentwood, TN Westshore Pizza & Cheesesteaks 4/6/17  
3.5 Columbia, TN Truelove’s Pizza and Grits 8/28/16  
3.5 Columbus, OH A Slice of New York 3/7/16  
3.5 Columbus, OH Rubino’s Pizzeria 5/29/15  
3.5 Columbus, OH Mikey’s Late Night Slice 11/13/15  
3.5 Dallas, TX Coal Vines 5/16/18  
3.5 Denver, CO Slice Works 4/23/17  
3.5 Destin, FL La Famiglia 7/2/17  
3.5 Destin, FL Pazzo Italiano Destin 1/10/22  
3.5 Elizabeth, NJ Bella Pizza 1/18/15  
3.5 Flushing, NY Amore Pizzeria 2/16/19  
3.5 Fords, NJ Angelo’s Pizzeria 9/1/19  
3.5 Ft. Myers, FL Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza 9/21/20  
3.5 Fort Worth, TX Cane Rosso 5/13/19  
3.5 Fort Worth, TX Joe’s Pizza & Pasta (Bryant Irvin) 8/25/13  
3.5 Fort Worth, TX NY Joe’s Pasta & Pizza (Alta Mere) 1/26/13  
3.5 Fort Worth, TX Rocco’s Wood-Fired Pizza 2/4/17  
3.5 Fort Worth, TX Slice City Pizza 5/17/19  
3.5 Fort Worth, TX The Pizza Snob 5/18/15  
3.5 Franklin, TN Coal Town Pizza 11/6/21  
3.5 Franklin, TN Cool Springs Brewery 5/23/13  
3.5 Franklin, TN Gina’s Stonefired Italian Pizzeria 1/8/15  
3.5 Franklin, TN Mineo’s Pizza, Wings & Raw Bar 8/12/12  
3.5 Garfield, NJ Pizza Mania / Gelato Mania 4/5/15  
3.5 Hollywood, CA Combo’s New York Pizzeria 1/5/16  
3.5 Huacas, Costa Rica Mama Mia Pizzeria 4/20/19  
3.5 Iselin, NJ Florio’s Restaurant & Pizzeria  5/24/20  
3.5 Jersey City, NJ Christos Deli & Pizzeria 2/10/14  
3.5 King of Prussia, PA Angelo’s Pizza Co. 5/27/19  
3.5 Knoxville, TN Dazzo’s 8/25/14  
3.5 Los Angeles, CA Lamonicas NY-Pizza 2/10/19  
3.5 Louisville, KY Spinelli’s Pizzeria 7/25/12 9/24/14
3.5 Marietta, GA Marietta Pizza Company 10/3/13  
3.5 Memphis, TN Little Italy  3/14/14  
3.5 Montgomery, AL Tomatinos Pizza & Bake Shop 8/6/14  
3.5 Montgomery, AL Sa Za 2/3/19  
3.5 Nashville, TN 312 Pizza Company 12/14/16  
3.5 Nashville, TN Al Taglio 5/9/14  
3.5 Nashville, TN Coco’s Italian Market 12/10/13  
3.5 Nashville, TN DeSano Pizza & Bakery 5/15/2014  
3.5 Nashville, TN Emmy Squared 8/12/2018  
3.5 Nashville, TN Night Train Pizza 5/2/2018  
3.5 New York, NY John’s Pizzeria of Times Square 7/31//14  
3.5 New York, NY Little Italy Pizza 7/24/16  
3.5 New York, NY Nick’s Pizza 3/25/17  
3.5 Nashville, TN North Italia 10/12/21  
3.5 New York, NY Numero 28 1/2/20  
3.5 New York, NY Ribalta 11/11/20  
3.5 New York, NY Rizzo’s Fine Pizza 3/7/20  
3.5 New York, NY Rosario’s Pizza 2/22/15  
3.5 New York, NY Stage Door Pizza 7/14/15  
3.5 New York, NY Steve’s Pizza 7/14/15  
3.5 Nolensville, TN Amico’s Pizza 8/12/12  
3.5 Orange, NJ  Star Tavern 11/15/14  
3.5 Panama City Beach, FL Panama Pizzeria 8/10/14 7/5/2015
3.5 Piscataway, NJ Gianni’s Pizzarama 12/7/19  
3.5 Piscataway Township, NJ Stelton Pizza and Restaurant 2/25/19  
3.5 Pittsburgh, PA Aiello’s Pizza 9/4/17  
3.5 Port Chester, NY Antonio’s Pizzeria 6/13/18  
3.5 Prattville, AL Midtown Pizza Kitchen 1/8/09  
3.5 Rome, ITALY Club Kave 10/2/15  
3.5 San Francisco, CA Bus Stop Pizza 3/4/18  
3.5 San Francisco, CA Escape from New York Pizza 12/22/16  
3.5 San Francisco, CA Nizario’s Pizza 3/9/18  
3.5 Scottsdale, AZ NYPD Pizza 8/2/18  
3.5 Scottsdale, AZ Yo Pauly’s New York Pizza Co. 7/22/18  
3.5 Smyrna, TN Salvo’s Pizza 4/27/13  
3.5 South Lake Tahoe, CA Slice of Sierra Pizza Co. 1/25/20  
3.5 South Lake Tahoe, CA Vinny’s Pizzeria 2/9/20  
3.5 Spring Hill, TN Nelly’s Italian Café 10/12/14  
3.5 Spring Hill, TN Viking Pizza Company 4/24/22  
3.5 [Various locations] Brixx 4/8/13  
3.5 [Various locations] Marco’s Pizza 3/23/13  
3.5 Watercolor, FL Pizza by the Sea 10/7/12 6/14/16
3.5 Weatherford, TX Joe’s Pasta N Pizza 3/14/16  
3.5 Weatherford, TX Pastafina Italian Restaurant  3/6/14  
3 Atlanta, GA Gino’s NY Pizza Bar 8/1/12  
3 Bayonne, NJ Bayview Pizzeria 11/6/16  
3 Bayonne, NJ Bayonne Patio Bar & Grille 5/28/17  
3 Blue Mountain Beach, FL Johnny McTighe’s Irish Pub 6/5/13  
3 Columbus, OH Donatos Pizza 11/22/15  
3 Fort Worth, TX Joe’s Pizza & Pasta(Hulen) 1/26/13  
3 Franklin, TN Mafiaoza’s 4/6/19  
3 Franklin, TN Nashville Pizza Company 9/1/15  
3 Franklin, TN Pie Five Pizza Co. 8/24/15  
3 Guanacaste, Costa Rica Britt Café Bakery 5/4/19  
3 Jersey City, NJ Helen’s Pizza 6/24/20  
3 London, UK Slice and More 10/21/18  
3 Louisville, KY BoomBozz Taphouse 9/10/13  
3 Louisville, KY Papalino’s Pizzeria 7/25/12 8/27/15
3 Miramar Beach, FL Ciao Belle Pizza da Guglielmo 6/29/16  
3 Nashville, TN Bellagio Pizza & Subs 7/1/17  
3 Nashville, TN Midnight Oil 3/17/21  
3 Nashville, TN Slim & Husky’s Pizza Beeria 4/12/17  
3 Newark, NJ Dickie Dee’s Pizza 11/6/13  
3 New Orleans, LA New York Pizza 11/24/12  
3 New Orleans, LA Vieux Carre 11/27/12  
3 New York, NY Highline Pizzeria 5/27/17  
3 New York, NY Mike’s Pizza 12/27/17  
3 New York, NY Previti Pizza 7/24/16  
3 New York, NY Slice & Co. 5/26/17  
3 New York, NY Thin Crust Pizza 4/25/16  
3 Oak Ridge, TN Big Ed’s Pizza 12/29/15  
3 Ocean Springs, MS Tom’s Extreme Pizzeria 3/22/15  
3 Panama City Beach, FL New York Pizza & Grill 11/26/20  
3 Paterson, NJ Broadway Pizza 4/3/18  
3 Philadelphia, PA Lorenzo and Sons Pizza 7/7/19  
3 Pittsburgh, PA Napoli Pizzeria 9/3/18  
3 San Francisco, CA Primo Pizza 12/22/16  
3 Sarasota, FL Rico’s Pizzeria 10/27/19  
3 Seaside, FL  Bud & Alley’s Pizza Bar 10/7/12  
3 Sedona, AZ Famous Pizza & Beer 7/14/18  
3 Sewanne, TN Crust 6/17/13  
3 Siesta Key, FL Solorzano’s Pizzeria 10/6/19  
3 St. Petersburg, FL Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen 9/17/19  
3 [Various locations] Whole Foods Market 10/23/12 1/26/21
3 Watersound, FL Sauce It Pizza 11/22/20  
3 Weatherford, TX The Pizza Place 1/12/13  
3 Willow Park, TX Alex’s Pizza, Pasta & Subs 12/22/17  
2.5 Atlantic City, NJ Three Brothers Pizza Palace 9/25/12  
2.5 Austin, TX Austin’s Pizza 10/29/13  
2.5 Austin, TX Cozzoli’s Pizza 10/26/13  
2.5 Bowling Green, KY Lost River Pizza Co. 12/16/12  
2.5 Columbus, OH Tommy’s Pizza 5/29/16  
2.5 Dallas, TX Eno’s Pizza Tavern 5/24/18  
2.5 Dallas, TX Tutta’s Pizza 2/23/20  
2.5 Franklin, TN Roma Pizza & Pasta 10/29/17  
2.5 Jersey City, NJ Loradella’s Family Pizzeria 1/22/17  
2.5 Knoxville, TN The Tomato Head 8/23/14  
2.5 Lansdowne, PA Paul Revere Pizza House 10/17/21  
2.5 London, UK Pizza Express 5/30/14  
2.5 Napa, CA Velo Pizzeria 2/21/18  
2.5 Nashville, TN Brooklyn Pizza and Café 7/10/21  
2.5 Nashville, TN Mafiaoza’s Pizzeria & Neighborhood Pub 1/26/13  
2.5 Nashville, TN Little Chicago 10/17/13  
2.5 Nashville, TN Luigi’s City Pizza 7/7/14  
2.5 Nashville, TN Soulshine Pizza Factory 9/18/13  
2.5 Nashville, TN Villalba Italian Restaurant 2/15/20  
2.5 Sanibel Island, FL The Great White Grill 8/16/20  
2.5 Seagrove Beach, FL Angelina’ Pizzeria & Pasta 10/7/12  
2.5 [Various locations] Old Chicago 1/11/13  
2.5 [Various locations] Publix 10/23/12  
2.5 [Various locations] Sbarro 12/9/12  
2 Atlanta, GA Baby Tommy’s Taste of New York 12/1/18  
2 Chattanooga, TN Mr. T’s Pizza and Ice Cream 8/22/18  
2 Columbus, OH Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza 9/29/12  
2 Fort Worth, TX Palio’s Pizza Café 2/22/14  
2 Fort Worth, TX Perrotti’s Pizza 2/26/14  
2 Franklin, TN Pieology 12/10/16  
2 Homewood, AL New York Pizza 8/19/14  
2 London, UK Best American Pizza 6/12/17  
2 Louisville, KY DeVino’s Deli 7/25/12  
2 Louisville, KY Impellizerri’s 1/2/13  
2 Louisville, KY Wick’s Pizza Parlor & Pub 11/25/15  
2 Nashville, TN Caesars Italian Restaurant 5/6/13  
2 Nashville, TN Sicilian Pizza & Pasta 8/15/12  
2 New York, NY Famous Original Ray’s (East Village) 12/24/14  
2 New York, NY Pizza Mercato 8/28/19  
2 Pittsburgh, PA Pizza Parma 9/3/18  
2 Pompeii, ITALY Pizza / Restaurant / Cafeteria  9/29/15  
2 San Francisco, CA Pizzelle Di North Beach 12/27/16  
2 Sarasota, FL Rico’s Pizzeria & Pasta House 11/25/19  
2 WaterSound Beach, FL Bruno’s Pizza 10/7/12 6/14/14
2 [Various locations] Famous Famiglia 2/18/17  
1.5 Fort Worth, TX Mama’s Pizza 9/5/13  
1.5 Knoxville, TN Davinci’s Pizzeria & Calzones 9/1/14  
1.5 New York, NY Champion Pizza 5/15/16  
1.5 Waco, TX Poppa Rollo’s Pizza 10/26/13  
1 Atlantic City, NJ Mario’s Pizza 2 9/25/12  
1 New York, NY 2 Bros. Pizza 10/23/12  
1 New York, NY 5 Boroughs Pizza 3/15/19  
1 [Various locations] Costco 8/12/12  
R.I.P. Atlanta, GA Ray’s New York Pizza 10/3/13 10/12/14
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Big Apple 1/22/14 12/10/16
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Chris’s Corner 12/10/13 12/4/16
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Grandpa’s Kitchen 10/1/16 10/21/18
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Lorenzo’s Pizza and Pasta 6/14/15 3/21/16
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Mario’s Pizza 4/6/13 9/20/14
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Naples Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant 7/14/14 12/22/15
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Pizza Notte 4/6/13  
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Ronny’s Pizzeria & Restaurant 5/3/14 12/18/14
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Tony’s Pizza 9/22/12 6/12/16
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Venice Restaurant 11/12/13 12/10/16
R.I.P. Bayonne, NJ Wild Wood Pizza & Penne 7/30/16  
R.I.P. Brentwood, TN Matteo’s Pizza 2/9/13 11/14/20
R.I.P. Brentwood, TN Sal’s Pizza 11/12/12 4/6/17
R.I.P. Franklin, TN Brothers’ Pizza Company 9/26/13 3/19/15
R.I.P. Franklin, TN Louie’s Bocce Club Pizza 8/12/12  
R.I.P. Franklin, TN Nick’s Italian Deli and Pizzeria 8/12/12 9/9/17
R.I.P. Franklin, TN Pizza and Cream 1/13/19  
R.I.P. Franklin, TN Wall Street Pizza 10/16/13 8/27/15
R.I.P. Jersey City, NJ Paulus Hook Pizza 10/14/12 8/9/20
R.I.P. Millbrook, AL Capone’s Pizza and Subs 5/27/13 3/20/14
R.I.P. Nashville, TN Music City Pizza 2/10/14 1/5/16
R.I.P. Nashville, TN Pizza Perfect Kebob 11/23/12 6/6/14
R.I.P. Nashville, TN DaVinci’s Gourmet Pizza 10/6/13  
R.I.P. New York, NY Famous Roio’s Pizza 7/8/12 12/1/13
R.I.P. New York, NY Fiore’s Pizza 12/20/14 1/10/21
R.I.P. Rosemary Beach Southside Slice Pizzeria 1/26/19 11/13/20
R.I.P. Santa Rosa Beach, FL Amore Pizzeria 10/7/12 6/14/16
R.I.P. Santa Rosa Beach, FL Christiano’s Ristorante 6/19/16 11/13/20
R.I.P. Santa Rosa Beach, FL Enzo’s Italian Restaurant 10/7/12 5/19/15
R.I.P. Secreast Beach, FL Acme Ice House 8/17/14 11/13/20
R.I.P. Seagrove Beach, FL Peppinos Pizzeria & Ice Cream Shop 5/23/15 6/13/16
R.I.P. Seagrove Beach, FL Pizza Nona 6/5/13 5/23/15
R.I.P. Spring Hill, TN Samboli’s 12/20/12 10/12/14

15 comments

  1. NY Pie Wins “Perfect Slice Award” | NY Pie Nashville · · Reply→

    […] We thank you for supporting our family business and are honored to be chosen when there were other great pizzerias you […]

  2. dook · · Reply→

    go to Pizza Suprema 8th ave 31 st nyc , then go to Don Pepi’s in New York Penn Station the Pizza is barely decent there except for the Meatball which is pretty phenomenal.

    1. mbodayle · · Reply→

      Awesome. Thanks for the tips. Back in NYC soon and will check them both out for sure.

  3. matt · · Reply→

    I see a bunch of new jersey places. Kinchleys tavern in Ramsey NJ is the best thin crust pizza ive ever had the pleasure to enjoy. I highly suggest you take a trip there one day

    1. mbodayle · · Reply→

      Thanks Matt–I have added it to my list. Going back home soon.

  4. MICHAEL KALMONSON · · Reply→

    NEXT TIME YOU ARE ON THE WEST COAST PLEASE CONTACT ME.I WORKED IN SOME PIZZA JOINTS AND BARS IN BAYONNE IN THE 1970’S.ONE OF THE TASTING PIZZA AROUND AT THAT TIME WAS BIMBO CUSEGLIO’S ON BDWAY RIGHT ACROSS FROM THE DEMOCRATIC CLUB.THOSE WHO KNEW HIM BIMBO WAS A GREAT GUY HE DID THE COOKING IN THE KITCHEN WHILE PAULIE CANCRO AND I TENDID THE BAR. BIMBOS BAR PIES WERE LEGENDARY BUT HIS SAUTEED SHIP WITH MEDIUM SAUCE WAS TO DIE FOR..SOON AFTER I LEFT TO GO WEST .BIMBOS HEALTH WAS BECOMING AN ISSUE AND THE PLACE WAS REINCARNATED AS PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPATS’Y DEANGELOS HE SPRUCED THE PLACE UP..BUT IN DOING SO THE PLACE MOST MUCH OF ITS CHARM.

    1. mbodayle · · Reply→

      Michael–thanks for your post. I was just a little kid back then, but I remembered those places! I will let you know if I go west again.

  5. Wendy · · Reply→

    You should try pizza town USA in Elmwood park, nj. Very good. Delmar in sheepshead bay in Brooklyn is very good also. If you ever go to little rock, ar try zaza’s.

    1. mbodayle · · Reply→

      Thanks so much for the tips–they’ve been noted!

  6. kelly · · Reply→

    Gotta try Colony Grill in CT!!

    1. mbodayle · · Reply→

      Man – the pie pictured at their website looks awesome – need to get there someday. Thanks for the tip.

  7. Scott James Price · · Reply→

    If you ever get to Northern Illinois I recommend Angelo’s in my hometown of Sterling, IL. Don’t worry, it’s not Chicago style pizza. My all time favorite and not just because I am from there…lol.

    1. mbodayle · · Reply→

      Thanks for the tip – I added to my list in case I ever go that way.

  8. David Schumacher · · Reply→

    Hello. If you get back to Tampa, definitely give Eddie & Sam’s in downtown Tampa a shot. And I have to recommend Rossini’s in Cheshire, Connecticut (my personal favorite, amazing sauce and crust, i could eat cold slices for breakfast everyday, where a large pizza is really large 18″ and for only $14.50 compared to these fancy places nowadays charging $20 plus for a 14″ pie). Plus, Pepes and Sallys in New Haven. I’m a big fan of the pizza in Connecticut, the crust has that special chew. I currently live near Asheville, NC and am still on the search for a good pizza place around here. I thought I found one called 928 Pizza but they ruined it with too much flour on the bottom. If I get a tongue full of flour your place is basically dead to me. Thank you for all of the reviews. I’m excited to try some of the places you mentioned in Nashville. -Dave

    1. mbodayle · · Reply→

      Thanks for the tips – man I sure miss travelling. Still longing to get to CT and I should get back to Tampa next year to see the Yankees play.

Leave a comment